If you only look at the price list, GPT-6.2 Astra and Claude Fable 5.2 look like twins: both charge $8 per million input tokens and $40 per million output tokens through their APIs, both arrived within eight days of each other in November 2026, and on the headline independent benchmark they sit just three points apart.
Your bill will not look like a tie, though. On the Artificial Analysis Intelligence Index, a full run of the test costs $4.00 per task with Astra and $26.54 per task with Fable. That is more than six times as much for three extra points — and only at Fable’s most expensive effort setting. At the effort levels where most real work happens, Astra ties or beats Fable while costing a fraction as much.
The honest answer: if you care about the score at any price, Fable 5.2 is the stronger model on several respected independent tests. If you care about what each point costs, Astra wins by a wide margin, and its smaller sibling Sol wins by even more. The right pick depends on which of those sentences matters more to your workload.
The launch in brief: two flagships, eight days apart
Anthropic shipped Claude Fable 5.2 on November 9, 2026; OpenAI answered on November 17 with GPT-6.2 Astra and GPT-6.2 Sol — eight days later. OpenAI calls Astra “the best model in the world for scientists,” a vendor claim the independent numbers back up in some places and not in others.
Both models are available in ChatGPT Work and Codex for Plus, Pro, Enterprise, and Edu customers — not on free accounts, and not in regular ChatGPT Chat. The API model IDs are gpt-6.2-astra and claude-fable-5-2, which is what you will see on your invoice.
Early tester reaction on X was lukewarm, with three of the best-known early testers calling the new models disappointing within the hour, according to Handy writing on Substack. First impressions are noisy, but the independent benchmarks below are a better guide than launch-week excitement.
Same list price, different bill: the pricing table
The headline rate is identical, so a quick glance suggests the models cost the same. They do not: caching, effort settings, and long-context surcharges pull the real price in different directions.
| Model | Input (per 1M tokens) | Output (per 1M tokens) | Cached input (per 1M tokens) |
|---|---|---|---|
| GPT-6.2 Astra | $8.00 | $40.00 | $0.40 |
| Claude Fable 5.2 | $8.00 | $40.00 | $0.20 (cache reads) |
| GPT-6.2 Sol | $2.00 | $10.00 | Not stated in this comparison |
| GPT-6 Astra (previous generation) | $10.00 | $50.00 | $1.00 |
Astra’s cached input rate is $0.40, down from $1.00 on GPT-6 Astra — a 60% cut that matters for agentic work, where the same context gets re-read across tool calls. Fable’s cache reads are cheaper still at $0.20, but its 5-minute cache writes cost $10 per million tokens, so heavy cache-write workloads can eat into that advantage.
Astra is also 20% cheaper than GPT-6 Astra on list price ($8/$40 against $10/$50), and Sol, at $2/$10, costs exactly a quarter of Astra. Keep Sol in mind — it keeps showing up as the quiet bargain of this launch. For the official rates, check OpenAI’s pricing page and Claude’s pricing page.
The long-context catch that can double your Astra bill
Before you pick Astra on price, read this part twice — it is the easiest way to get a surprise invoice.
Above 272,000 input tokens, OpenAI doubles Astra’s input and cached rates and raises its output rate by 50% — for the whole request. A long-context Astra call is billed at $16 per million input tokens and $60 per million output tokens, not $8 and $40. The surcharge reprices everything in the request, not just the tokens above the threshold.
If your agent routinely stuffs a 300,000-token codebase into context, your per-task cost can jump sharply even though the model looks cheap on the price list. Fable has no equivalent surcharge in the verified facts for this comparison, which narrows or even reverses Astra’s edge on very long-context work. Short and medium tasks — the bulk of coding help, drafting, and research — rarely trigger it. Long ones should be budgeted at the $16/$60 rates.
That is why “cost per task” beats “price per token” as a lens: it captures what the work costs after the model’s habits — how much it reasons, how much context it re-reads — are factored in. The independent benchmarks below report exactly that.
Benchmark by benchmark: scores and what each point costs
No single benchmark decides a model comparison — different tests reward different strengths, and the two models trade wins. The table below puts the verified independent results side by side, with the cost per task wherever it was published.
| Benchmark (independent unless noted) | GPT-6.2 Astra | Claude Fable 5.2 | Cost per task |
|---|---|---|---|
| Artificial Analysis Intelligence Index v5.0.1 | 62 | 65 | Astra $4.00; Fable $26.54 |
| Vals Index v2.2 | 67.66% | 71.31% | Astra $10.68; Fable $17.94 |
| FrontierCode 2.0 (agentic coding) | 45.4% | 49.1% | Fable $14.19 at xhigh; Fable max $44.70 |
| Vals Science Index | 68.44% | 63.74% | Not published |
| Terminal-Bench Science | 78.1% | 73.3% | Not published |
| Vals Vibe Code | 89.90% | 93.77% | Not published |
| Harvey LAB-AA (legal) | Leads at roughly 2x Fable’s pass rate | — | Not published |
| ARC-AGI-3 | 100% (vendor-reported) | Not stated | Not published |
Start with the headline test: the Artificial Analysis Intelligence Index v5.0.1 runs nine evaluations and reports a single score. Fable 5.2 tops it at 65; Astra reaches 62. Three points separate them — but Fable’s 65 costs $26.54 per task against Astra’s $4.00, more than six times as much. As the effort sweep below shows, most of that gap is effort, not raw capability. For context, Gemini 4 Carbon scores 60 and Claude Opus 5.5 scores 59.
The Vals Index v2.2 tells a similar story with a smaller price gap. Fable leads 71.31% to 67.66%, and the cost per test is $17.94 for Fable against $10.68 for Astra — about 68% more per test for a 3.65-point lead.
Then the pattern flips. On the Vals Science Index, Astra wins 68.44% to 63.74%, and on Terminal-Bench Science it wins 78.1% to 73.3%. If your work is scientific — literature review, data analysis, research reasoning — Astra is not the budget compromise. It is the better model on the independent science tests, and the cheaper one too. That is the context behind OpenAI’s “best model in the world for scientists” line: a vendor claim, but on these two tests the independent numbers point the same way.
Fable strikes back where taste and polish matter: on the Vals Vibe Code benchmark it scores 93.77% against Astra’s 89.90%. If you are building consumer-facing apps or demos, that lead is real.
On agentic coding, the FrontierCode 2.0 benchmark from Cognition — built on real codebases — Fable leads 49.1% to Astra’s 45.4%, reaching that score at xhigh effort for $14.19 per task. Fable’s own max setting is a cautionary tale: 45.7% at $44.70 per task, a worse score for more than three times the money. Effort matters more than model choice here.
The legal benchmark adds another Astra win. On the Harvey LAB-AA legal benchmark, Astra leads at roughly double Fable’s pass rate, according to OpenAI’s launch chart. The exact figures vary by scoring method, so no precise pair is printed here — but a lead of about two to one is not a rounding error, and it matters if your work involves contracts or compliance documents.
Finally, ARC-AGI-3: Astra is the first model to score 100%, according to OpenAI’s vendor-reported result. Treat that as a vendor claim, not an independent finding — but a perfect score on a reasoning test designed to resist memorization is still a notable marker.
One independent write-up of the cost gap is at RD World Online.
The effort sweep: the table that changes the whole comparison
If you read only one table in this article, make it this one: Artificial Analysis ran both models at five effort levels and recorded the score, cost, and time for each.
| Effort level | Astra score | Astra cost/task | Astra time | Fable score | Fable cost/task | Fable time |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Low | 46 | $0.66 | 1.4 min | 54 | $3.10 | Not stated |
| Medium | 57 | $1.62 | Not stated | 56 | $3.80 | Not stated |
| High | 60 | $2.07 | Not stated | 62 | $9.08 | 14.6 min |
| Xhigh | 62 | $2.52 | Not stated | 62 | $14.83 | Not stated |
| Max | 62 | $4.00 | 10.4 min | 65 | $26.54 | 40.8 min |
Three things jump out. At low effort Fable is clearly stronger — 54 against Astra’s 46 — but it costs nearly five times as much per task ($3.10 versus $0.66). At medium effort Astra pulls ahead on score, 57 to 56, at less than half the cost ($1.62 versus $3.80). At high effort, Fable retakes the lead, 62 to 60, but the price jumps to $9.08 against Astra’s $2.07 — more than four times as much for two points.
Most important: at xhigh effort, both models score 62. Fable ties Astra’s best score at $14.83 per task; Astra reaches the same 62 at $2.52. Only at max effort does Fable break the tie, reaching 65 at $26.54 — and taking 40.8 minutes per task, against 10.4 minutes for Astra’s max run. Three points, ten times the money, four times the wait.
That is the core insight: Fable’s headline lead is real, but it is a max-effort lead. Below max effort, Astra matches or beats Fable on score while costing far less. Unless your task genuinely needs Fable’s maximum reasoning, you are paying a large premium for points you may never use.
Worked monthly-bill math: what 500 tasks actually cost
Benchmark costs per task are abstract until you multiply them by your volume. Here is the simplest version, using the Artificial Analysis figures.
At 500 tasks a month:
- Astra at max effort: 500 × $4.00 = $2,000 per month
- Fable at max effort: 500 × $26.54 = $13,270 per month
- Difference: $11,270 per month, or $135,240 over a year
That is not a rounding difference — it is the difference between a tool budget and a headcount budget. Those 500 max-effort Fable tasks also take 40.8 minutes each on the benchmark’s timing, so you are paying more and waiting longer.
Now a more realistic mixed workload — nobody runs every task at max effort. Suppose your team runs 1,000 tasks a month: 600 quick tasks at low effort, 300 standard at medium, and 100 hard tasks at high effort.
With Astra: 600 × $0.66 = $396; 300 × $1.62 = $486; 100 × $2.07 = $207. Monthly total: $1,089.
With Fable at the same effort split: 600 × $3.10 = $1,860; 300 × $3.80 = $1,140; 100 × $9.08 = $908. Monthly total: $3,908.
Same 1,000 tasks, same effort mix — Fable costs $2,819 more per month, about 3.6 times Astra’s bill. On this mix, Astra scores 46, 57, and 60 against Fable’s 54, 56, and 62: Fable wins the easy tasks, Astra the middle tier, Fable the hard tier. Whether that is worth an extra $2,819 a month is a business decision, not a benchmark decision.
The point: do not choose on list price or headline score alone. Choose on cost per task at the effort level your work actually needs, multiplied by your volume. That is the only math that shows up on your invoice.
What OpenAI’s charts don’t show
OpenAI’s launch materials make a strong case for Astra, and some of it holds up. But three gaps deserve a straight look.
First, the cost claim does not survive independent checking. OpenAI says Astra beats Fable 5.2 by 5.5 points on Agents’ Last Exam at about 5% of the cost per task, and beats GPT-6 Astra by 5.2 points at under a third of the cost. The independent numbers are more modest: Artificial Analysis measures the saving against GPT-6 Astra at 36% ($4.00 versus $6.24), not the roughly 67% saving “under a third” implies, and Vals AI measures about 50% ($10.68 versus $21.28). Both are real savings; neither is “under a third.” A detailed independent check of the gap is at TechTimes.
Second, the headline Artificial Analysis score for Fable carries a label you should know about: the Fable 5.2 max score of 65 is labelled “Default Fallback,” signalling that something about the run’s configuration was not the standard setup. Read the 65 with a note of caution rather than as a clean like-for-like result. It does not erase Fable’s lead — Fable also leads on the Vals Index, where no such label applies — but the three-point gap is not as tidy as a single number makes it look.
Third, OpenAI’s own Agents’ Last Exam chart excluded nine Fable tasks. The exclusion may have a legitimate technical reason, and it may not change the headline — but a chart that quietly drops nine of the competitor’s results is not the same as one that includes them. Independent benchmarks exist precisely because vendor charts are built to sell a model.
None of this makes Astra a bad model — its independent results are strong enough that it does not need generous charts. Trust the independent cost-per-task numbers over the vendor’s cost claims, and read every launch chart as an argument, not a measurement.
Don’t sleep on Sol: the real bargain of this launch
Every comparison of Astra and Fable risks missing the third model in the room. GPT-6.2 Sol scores 57 on the Artificial Analysis index at $1.01 per task — the same 57 last generation’s flagship GPT-6 Astra scores, at about 15% of its cost per task. Sol’s list price is $2 input and $10 output per million tokens, a quarter of Astra’s rates.
Put that next to the effort sweep: Sol at $1.01 per task delivers a 57, the same score Astra reaches at medium effort for $1.62 and Fable reaches for $3.80. For everyday work — drafting, summarizing, first-pass analysis, routine coding help — Sol gives you flagship-last-year quality at a price that barely registers on a monthly bill.
That is why the framework below puts Sol first for routine work. If you are choosing between Astra and Fable for everything, you are probably overpaying for the easy half of your workload. Route the easy work to Sol, spend the Astra or Fable money where the task earns it, and your blended cost per task drops sharply without giving up much quality. For more on Sol, see our earlier look at OpenAI GPT-6 Sol and Luna in Codex.
Which model for which job: a decision framework
There is no single winner. The right model depends on the job, the volume, and what a mistake costs you.
High-volume documents, legal work, and science: Astra. Astra leads the Harvey LAB-AA legal benchmark at roughly double Fable’s pass rate, wins both independent science tests, and costs $4.00 per task against Fable’s $26.54 at max effort. If you process contracts, research papers, or large document sets all day, Astra gives you the better score and the smaller bill. Watch the long-context surcharge above 272,000 input tokens — if your documents routinely cross that line, re-run the math at the $16/$60 rates.
Agentic coding where quality beats cost: Fable — at xhigh, not max. Fable leads FrontierCode 2.0 at 49.1% against Astra’s 45.4%, and it leads the Vibe Code benchmark too. Buy that lead at xhigh effort ($14.19 per task), not max ($44.70 for a worse 45.7% score) — max is the one setting where Fable costs the most and scores less. If your coding agent runs unattended and a wrong merge is expensive, Fable at xhigh is the right splurge; if you review every output anyway, Astra’s 45.4% at a far lower cost is hard to argue against.
Everyday work, drafting, and routine help: Sol. A score of 57 at $1.01 per task is the best value in this launch. Use Sol for first drafts, summaries, email help, and routine code — anything where a good answer is enough — and reserve Astra and Fable for tasks that earn their price.
When you need the absolute best score and cost is no object: Fable at max. Fable’s 65 on the Artificial Analysis index and 71.31% on the Vals Index are the best numbers in this comparison. If one task justifies $26.54 — a high-stakes analysis, a complex research problem, a flagship demo — Fable at max is the strongest model here. Just know what it costs in money and time: 40.8 minutes per task on the benchmark’s timing.
For the broader pricing picture, see our comparison of Gemini 4, GPT-6 Astra, and Claude flagship pricing for 2026. And if you are a freelancer weighing Fable, our earlier piece on Claude Fable 5.2’s 20 percent price cut covers how that cut changes the math for solo operators.
The bottom line
GPT-6.2 Astra and Claude Fable 5.2 share a $8/$40 list price — and that is where the similarity ends. Fable is the stronger model at maximum effort: a 65 on the Artificial Analysis index, 71.31% on the Vals Index, the lead on agentic coding and vibe coding. Astra is the better value nearly everywhere else: a 62 on the same index for $4.00 instead of $26.54 per task, wins on both science benchmarks, and a lead of about two to one on the legal test.
The smartest setup for most teams is all three: Sol for routine work at $1.01 a task, Astra for high-volume professional work where it leads on score and price together, and Fable at xhigh effort for the coding and creative jobs where its quality edge is worth paying for. Run your own volume through the math above, watch the 272,000-token line on Astra, and let your invoice — not the launch charts — make the final call.
Frequently Asked Questions
Are GPT-6.2 Astra and Claude Fable 5.2 really the same price?
On list price, yes: both charge $8 per million input tokens and $40 per million output tokens through their APIs. In practice they are not the same price, because caching rates differ and the models burn different amounts of reasoning per task. Cost per task is what matters: $4.00 for Astra and $26.54 for Fable on the Artificial Analysis index.
Which model scores higher on independent benchmarks?
It depends on the test. Fable leads the Artificial Analysis index 65 to 62 and the Vals Index 71.31% to 67.66%, plus FrontierCode 2.0 and Vals Vibe Code. Astra leads the Vals Science Index 68.44% to 63.74%, Terminal-Bench Science 78.1% to 73.3%, and the Harvey LAB-AA legal benchmark at roughly double Fable’s pass rate.
Why does Fable cost so much more per task if the token price is identical?
Because Fable uses far more reasoning effort to reach its top scores: its max-effort run takes 40.8 minutes per task, against 10.4 minutes for Astra’s max run. More reasoning means more tokens, and more tokens means a bigger bill. At xhigh effort, Fable ties Astra’s best score of 62 at $14.83 per task, against Astra’s $2.52.
What is the Astra long-context surcharge?
Above 272,000 input tokens, OpenAI doubles Astra’s input and cached rates and raises output by 50% for the whole request — $16 per million input and $60 per million output tokens. The surcharge applies to the entire request, not just the tokens above the threshold. Short and medium tasks are unaffected; very long-context work should be budgeted at the higher rates.
Should I use GPT-6.2 Sol instead of Astra or Fable?
For routine work, yes. Sol scores 57 on the Artificial Analysis index at $1.01 per task — the same score as the previous flagship GPT-6 Astra at about 15% of its cost per task, and the same score Astra reaches at medium effort for $1.62. Use Sol for drafting, summaries, and everyday help, and save Astra or Fable for tasks that need their extra capability.
Is OpenAI’s claim that Astra costs under a third of GPT-6 Astra accurate?
Not according to independent checks: Artificial Analysis measures 36% ($4.00 versus $6.24 per task), and Vals AI measures about 50% ($10.68 versus $21.28). Both are real savings, but both fall well short of the roughly 67% saving “under a third” implies. Budget on the independent figures, not the vendor’s claim.
